PROPERTY COMPARISON WITH GASOLINE

Like gasoline, ethanol is liquid at room temperature and pressure. It can be handled and dispensed using equipment designed for gasoline-with some modi­fications to accommodate material incompatibilities as discussed above. Most consumers would not notice any difference when fueling their vehicles using E85.

One of the major differences between using E85 and gasoline affecting engine operation is due to the differences in vapor pressure and latent heat of vaporiza­tion. In order for combustion to begin in an engine, a portion of the fuel must be vaporized. Gasoline is a mixture of many hydrocarbon compounds with varied vapor pressures and latent heats of vaporization. This means that even under cold conditions a portion of gasoline will still evaporate. Because ethanol is a pure substance, it becomes difficult to vaporize when cold. In fact ethanol will not form an air/fuel vapor mixture high enough to support combustion below 11°C.12 This led to the use of E85. Gasoline is added to the ethanol in order to support cold startability. Most E85 is blended with regular grade unleaded gasoline.

A comparison of E85 and gasoline is presented in Table 8.1. One complication in using values from this table is the fact that E85 is made from ethanol that has been denatured with up to 5% gasoline; thus E85 is usually composed of less than 85% pure ethanol. This means that the data in Table 8.1 is an approximation of E85 as it is based upon a true blend of 85% ethanol.

Further, E85 is determined on a volume basis, but many users mistakenly use a mass basis in order to determine its composition.3 Fortunately, the densities of gasoline and E85 are similar as shown in Table 8.1. Assuming constant component volumes during mixing, 85% ethanol on a volume basis produces about 85.7% ethanol on a mass basis.

Finally, the actual blends of E85 are seasonally adjusted depending on the geographical region and the season. During warm weather the blends have higher levels of ethanol to lower vapor pressure; thus minimizing evaporative emissions and vapor lock. These blends of E85 typically contain 85% denatured ethanol. While in cold weather, more gasoline is added to the blend to avoid starting problems. Most winter blends of E85 are actually 70% ethanol by volume. Of course, the gasoline, too, is seasonally adjusted to minimize vapor pressure during the warmer months and to aid in cold startability during the colder months. As one can see, the values in Table 8.1 are simply nominal values. Samples of E85 used in emissions testing should first be analyzed by a qualified laboratory to obtain precise property values.

American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standards for E85 are presented in the following table. These standards, although generally voluntary, are usually followed by major fuel producers. Table 8.2 lists physical properties

TABLE 8.1

Physical Fuel Properties

Gasoline-Regular

Physical Property

Unleaded

Ethanol

E85

Formulation

C4 to C12 H/C —

C2H5OH

85% Ethanol (vol)

chains

15 % Gasoline (vol)

Average Analysis (% mass)

C: 85-88

C: 52

C: 57

H: 12-15

H: 13

H: 13

O:35

O: 30

Octane — (R + M)/2

87

98-100

96

Specific Gravity

0.72-0.78

0.794

0.785

(60/65 F)

Lower Heating Value —

18,500

11,500

12,500

Btu/lbm(KJ/Kg)

(43000)

(26750)

(29080)

Lower Heating Value — Btu/gal

115,700

76,200

81,900

(KJ/liter)

(32,250)

(21,240)

(22,830)

Reid Vapor Pressure — psi (kPa)

8-15

2.3

6-12

(50-100)

(15)

(41-83)

Heat of Vaporization — Btu/lbm

140-170

362-400

349

(KJ/Kg)

(330-400)

(842-930)

(812)

Flammability Limits — % Fuel

1-8

3-19

(volume)

Stoichiometric A/F (mass)

14.7

9

10

Conductivity — (mhos/cm)

1 X 10-14

1.35 X 10-9

Source: Data compiled from Davis, G., et al., Society of Automotive Engineers, 1999-01-0609, 1999; U. S. Department of Energy, DOE/GO-1002001-956, Revised Oct. 2002; Society of Auto­motive Engineers, 930376, 1993.

for the different seasonal blends. Note that this table lists the true levels of pure ethanol; thus the levels appear lower than expected due to the gasoline used as the denaturant in the ethanol.

Class 1 (minimum 79% ethanol) is generally considered summer blend; it is used by most states during the warm months. This is the fuel that is closest to “true” E85. Classes 2 and 3 are considered winter, or spring/fall blends. Class 2 (minimum 74% ethanol) is generally used during spring and fall in cooler cli­mates, and in the winter in mild climates. Class 3 (minimum 70% ethanol) is used during the winter, early spring and late fall, in cooler climates.

One additional property of ethanol that is not shown in either table is its high miscibility with water. Water entrainment in the ethanol can cause the ethanol and gasoline to separate, leading to vehicle stalls and poor drivability.15 Fuel handling and storage systems must be designed to keep moisture levels out of the fuel. On the positive side, regular use of E85 helps to eliminate moisture in vehicle fuel storage systems as the moisture is entrained in the ethanol and then removed from the system.

TABLE 8.2

ASTM D5798-99 Specification for Seasonal Blends of E85

ASTM

Physical Property Value for Class Test Method

ASTM volatility

1

2

3

Minimum level of ethanol (plus

79

74

70

D5501

higher alcohols) — % volume

Hydrocarbons (including

17-21

17-26

17-30

D4815

denaturant) — % volume

Vapor pressure ( 37.8°C) — psi

5.5-8.5

7.0-9.5

9.5-12.0

D4953, D5190,

(kPa)

(38-59)

(48-65)

(66-83)

D5191

Sulfur (maximum) — mg/kg

210

260

300

D3120, D1266, D2622

Water (maximum) — % mass

1.0

1.0

1.0

E203

Acidity (as acetic acid) — ppm

50

50

50

D1613

Source: U. S. Department of Energy DOE/GO-1002001-956, Revised Oct. 2002.