Energy Saving Dissolution of Plant Biomass

As described in the above two sections, ILs are promising solvents to treat plant biomass. The most important thing is the treatment capability of plant biomass under mild conditions. CDILs dissolve polysaccharides and a part of lignin at about 100 °C without any pressurization; this means that the energy-cost to treat biomass was reduced compared to other existing biomass treatment processes under heating above 150 °C and pressurization. It is very important for any industrial fields because energy-cost is directly linked to the price of the final product. The con­sumption of energy becomes of particular importance for the energy-producing industry, because the use of excess amount of energy to get comparable or less energy is meaningless. Although ILs can treat plant biomass under mild condition compared to some other methods such as kraft-pulping method, heating and long mixing time are still needed to dissolve plant biomass in ILs, too. These require­ments should further be improved to reduce energy consumption.

Some researcher use ILs for just pretreatment of plant biomass and not for dissolution of cellulose. Li and co-workers reported that enzymatic hydrolysis was significantly improved by the use of CDIL, 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium diethyl phosphate ([C2mim][DEP]) [66]. They investigated the effect of tempera­ture and time of the IL treatment on the hydrolysis efficiency. The pretreatment temperature was changed from 25 to 150 °C for 1 h stirring, and the hydrolysis efficiency of the pretreated wheat straw was significantly improved when the temperature was changed from 70 to 100 °C. On the other hand, the difference of the pretreatment time slightly affects the hydrolysis degree, and they reached the conclusion that only 30 min treatment was enough to accelerate the following hydrolysis. The yield of reducing sugars from wheat straw reached 54.8 % when the wheat straw was pretreated with [C2mim][DEP] at 130 °C for only 30 min. It remained only 20 % when the straw was enzymatically hydrolyzed in water for 12 h. In addition, the hydrolysis products did not show a negative effect on

S. cerevisiae fermentation. Tan and co-workers reported the IL pretreatment of palm frond after extracting the palm oil for improving conversion of cellulose into reducing sugar through subsequent enzymatic hydrolysis [67]. During the pretreatment, lignin was partly decomposed and was dissolved in [C4mim]Cl and remained in the solution after regeneration process of cellulose. In addition, hemi — cellulose was autohydrolyzed during the pretreatment. Apart from crystallinity of cellulose, cellulose digestibility should also be influenced by other factors such as DP, surface area of cellulose, as well as state of cellulose protected by lignin and hemicellulose complexes. Uju and co-workers also studied the effect of pretreatment with ILs for plant biomass [68]. They used [C4mpy]Cl as a pretreatment IL for bagasse or Eucalyptus. The pretreatment of the biomass resulted in up to eightfold increase in the enzymatic saccharification compared with the untreated biomass. At short time pretreatment, [C4mpy]Cl showed higher potential to increase the initial degree of cellulose conversion than that in [C2mim][OAc]. They suggested that the significant acceleration of enzymatic saccharification was possibly caused by the reducing of DP of cellulose by the [C4mpy]Cl pretreatment. Bahcegul and co-workers studied the correlation between the particle size of plant biomass in detail and the pretreatment efficiency with ILs for subsequent enzymatic saccharification [69]. They used cotton stalks with four different particle size pretreated in [C2mim][OAc] or [C2mim]Cl. For [C2mim]Cl, the highest glucose yield (49 %) was obtained when the biomass had the smallest particle size, while cotton stalks with larger particle size gave lower glucose yield (33 %). On the contrary, for [C2mim][OAc], the lowest glucose yield (57 %) was obtained when the cotton stalks with the smallest particle size was examined, while cotton stalks with larger particle size gave higher glucose yield (71 %). Simply consider­ing the overall surface area of the biomass particles, smaller particles gave higher glucose yield. Other unknown factor(s) should exist to affect the enzymatic saccharification. They suggested that the most suitable particle size of lignocellu — losic biomass prior to pretreatment may change depending on the IL species.

For pretreatment of lignocellulosic biomass, it is not necessary to completely dissolve cellulose but heating is still a necessary step. On the other hand, some researchers are trying to dissolve plant biomass without heating. Abe et al. found that phosphinate-type ILs dissolved plant biomass and extracted polysaccharides from plant biomass without heating [70]. Since some phosphonate type ILs as seen in Scheme 2.9 have a good ability to dissolve cellulose at ambient temperature [28], we have prepared several phosphonate type ILs and evaluated their biomass treatment ability. As a result, polysaccharide extraction degree was found to be closely related to the viscosity. This means that the IL with low viscosity had good

image75

image76,Scheme 2.10 Structure of 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium phosphinate (IL14) (Reproduced from Abe et al. [70] with permission from The Royal Society of Chemistry),Fig. 2.8 Extraction degree of polysaccharides from bran using phophinate salt (IL14) or methylphosphonate salt (IL5) [70] ,image77

Scheme 2.9 Structure of alkylphosphonate type salts [70]

capacity to dissolve plant biomass within a short period of mixing time under mild condition when ILs have sufficiently high polarity. We accordingly designed a low viscosity and highly polar IL; 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium phosphinate (Scheme 2.10). With this IL, it became easy to extract polysaccharides rapidly from plant biomass under mild conditions (Fig. 2.8). Since this IL did not require any heating to extract polysaccharides from biomass, the energy-cost was reduced and this IL should be a promising solvent for plant biomass treatment. In addition, this IL is stable and recyclable. Thus, a closed system for biomass treatment as seen in Fig. 2.9 can be proposed.

image78

Fig. 2.9 Closed and energy-saving system (scheme) to extract polysaccharides from plant biomass [70]

Table 2.10 Correlation between water content of TBPH and extraction degree of polysaccharides after 1 h stirring at 25 °C

Water content of TBPH solution (wt%)

Polysaccharides extraction degree (%)

70

4.9

60

28

50

36

40

37

30

24

The extraction degree was calculated from the weight of the added poplar powder (5 wt% against the TBPH solution)

There are a few reports about the effect of water addition on the solubility of cellulose. Padmanabhan and co-workers reported about the influence of water on the lignocellulose solubility [71]. Prior to solubility measurements, 3-5 wt% water was added to cellulose dissolving ILs, namely chloride, acetate and phosphate — based ILs. After that, powder of Miscanthus, a lignocellulosic material, was added to the ILs, and stirred the mixture at over 100 °C. However, no cellulose was extracted. This result strongly suggested that water considerably suppressed the dissolution of lignocellulose in wet ILs. They concluded that ILs should be dried well in advance to extract cellulose from biomass. Since plant biomasses also contain a certain amount of water, the biomasses have to be dried before treatment with ILs. On the other hand, as mentioned above, TBPH has a great ability to dissolve cellulose without heating even in the presence of water [47]. So, we next tried to use this novel solvent to treat wood biomass. As expected, polysaccharides such as cellulose were extracted from wood powder without heating (Table 2.10). Poplar powder was used as a wood sample, and the powder was added to reach 5 wt% against TBPH solution. In the presence of 70 wt% water, TBPH could extract polysaccharides only 4.9 % of the weight of the added poplar. On the other hand, TBPH containing 40-50 wt% water successfully extracted cellulose and other polysaccharides for 36-37 % of the weight of the added popular. These results indicate that the extraction of cellulose from powder of wood such as poplar could be carried out even in the presence of considerable amounts of water.

For the development of sustainable human societies, we have to develop new energy conversion methods based on renewable energy sources instead of fossil fuels. ILs, which dissolve renewable cellulosic biomass with low energy cost, should serve as the foundation for future development of sustainable world, espe­cially for the development of bioenergy production.

Acknowledgement Our research results mentioned here were obtained under the support of a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science (No. 21225007). It was also partly supported by Japan Science and Technology Agency (JST) through the CREST program.