Energy balance for conventional bioethanol production

It assumed that the amount of energy in feed stock wet biomass is 100 and that 50% of this energy consists of that from reactant sugars, such as starch, cellulose and others. Thus, the amount of energy of the original component of sugar (50) transfers to ethanol (46) and heat (4) through chemical reactions (saccharification and fermentation) with water. This energy is estimated from the following calculation; the caloric value of sugar is 685 kcal/mol, the caloric value of ethanol is 316 kcal/mol and 2 mol ethanol is produced from 1 mol sugar through the above reaction. The pure ethanol product is then separated by distillation and additional heat energy (23) is required for this distillation work when azeotropic distillation is used for the separation. Non-reactants contain a large amount of water, for which the higher heat value is almost equal to the evaporation heat, leading to a net heat value of 0. The above energy relation is shown in Fig. 1. Beyond this, some additional energy is required to produce heat energy from the wet biomass for distillation (23). This additional energy (15) is used to dry the wet biomass in a heater to produce dry biomass that is used as fuel for distillation. Figure 2 shows the total energy balance including this additional energy. It is noted that 50-80% moisture content in wet biomass is assumed in this energy analysis, because many types of wet biomass exist in this range, such as those that originate from ligneous, garbage and sludge. It can be seen from Fig. 2 that 138 units of energy in the wet biomass feed stock is required to produce 46 energy units of ethanol and that about 1/3 of the energy of the wet biomass can be utilized as bioethanol for fuel. Thus, 2/3 of the wet biomass feed stock energy is wasted. Even though this wasted heat energy could potentially be heat sources for other processes, the exergy ratio and temperature of the waste heats are quite low. Thus, it is difficult to achieve energy saving from this by heat integration technologies such as cascading utilization. In fact, the highest required temperature during bioethanol production is normally at the distillation column reboiler and this temperature is lower than 150 °C. This heat is exhausted from the condenser at below 100 °C. To utilize the biomass energy more effectively, it is clear that the energy consumption during distillation for separating water and product ethanol and for drying of the wet biomass must be reduced. When an integrated system of distillation and membrane separation processes are utilized to substitute for azeotropic distillation, the energy required can be decreased from 23 to 12 units (8: distillation, 4: membrane separation). However, the pressure difference for membrane separation requires electric power. If we assume that the power generation efficiency from dry biomass is 25% and 75% of the energy for the membrane separation process is provided by electricity, 35 energy units from wet biomass are required for distillation and dehydration by membrane separation.

image101

image102

2. Self-heat recuperation technology and self-heat recuperative processes

Self-heat recuperation technology (Kansha et al. 2009) facilitates recirculation of not only latent heat but also sensible heat in a process, and helps to reduce the energy consumption of the process by using compressors and self-heat exchangers based on exergy recuperation. In this technology, i) a process unit is divided on the basis of functions to balance the heating and cooling loads by performing enthalpy and exergy analysis, ii) the cooling load is recuperated by compressors and exchanged with the heating load. As a result, the heat of the process stream is perfectly circulated without heat addition, and thus, the energy consumption for the process can be greatly reduced. By applying this technology to each process (distillation and dehydration), the energy balance for the ethanol production can be changed significantly from that described above. In this section, the design methodology for self-heat recuperative processes is introduced by using a basic thermal process, and the self­heat recuperative processes applied to the separation processes are then introduced.