The Need for Neutrons

Despite the superficial similarity of the application of neutrons with those of photons, neutrons have some key differences to photons that enable neutron-based techniques to play a particularly important role in the sustainable-energy area. A full account of neutron theory and techniques is given elsewhere in this series [1] with key methods prevalent in this book outlined here. For our purposes we can regard all of the advantages and disadvantages of neutron scattering as having a single origin: neutrons interact with, and are sometimes scattered by, atomic nuclei. In all neutron-scattering methods this leads the following advantages:

i. The scattering characteristics of each type of isotopic nucleus are well known, but vary almost randomly from one isotope type to another (scattering-lengths are shown in Fig. 1.1). This provides considerable scope for measuring light nuclei in the presence of very heavy nuclei, and also changing the scattering length by using a different isotope of the same element. For materials such as lithium-ion battery electrodes, where lithium must be probed in the presence of transition metals (see Chap. 7), this is a considerable advantage over other techniques where the scattering arises from electron density.

ii. Incoherence arises when scattering from the nuclei do not interfere construc­tively. The random relation between the nuclear spins of hydrogen and neighbouring atoms contributes to the extreme incoherent neutron-scattering cross-section of the 1H nucleus, which can be turned off by simple deuteration. Hydrogen is probably the most important element in sustainable energy — materials and it is very convenient that neutron scattering provides this selectable sensitivity for this element.

iii. Neutron-scattering cross sections are in general quite small, so neutrons are relatively penetrating, where measurements (reflection is an exception) occur for the bulk of the sample. This penetration alleviates the need for special window materials in difficult sample environments and in situ studies. There are good examples of this in Chap. 7 for lithium-ion batteries in which the com­position of the electrodes can easily be measured in an operating battery.

iv. Neutron-absorption cross sections are also normally quite low, contributing to the high penetration of neutrons, but some isotopes have very large absorption. Lithium is perhaps the second most important element in sustainable-energy materials, so it is again convenient that 6Li has high absorption, whilst 7Li does not. Consequently, either radiography (and other bulk techniques) or normal neutron-scattering experiments can be made using the appropriate isotopic composition.

image001

Fig. 1.1 Neutron-scattering lengths and X-ray scattering amplitudes for various isotopes (neutrons based on naturally-abundant isotopes unless specifically identified) and elements (X-rays)

The list above shows that neutron scattering is well suited to the study of sustainable-energy materials, but there are other important considerations to be made before undertaking a neutron experiment. Firstly, neutrons are difficult to produce in high quantities with the correct energies for the studies in this book, and consequently, virtually all experiments require a central facility and associated logistics. Secondly, even at the most powerful sources the neutron beams are weak when compared with photons or electrons, so the samples and the counting times for neutrons are correspondingly greater. Consequently, neutron scattering is rarely used when the desired information can be obtained by another means, and maxi­mum use of complementary techniques (most frequently X-ray) and computer­modelling methods is common.