The 1957 Windscale Fire

1.1 Events Leading to the Accident

In the early hours of the morning on the 10th of October 1957 a reactor (Number 1 of the two Windscale ‘‘Piles’’), developed to produce plutonium and tritium for the UK’s atomic bomb programme, caught fire. The fire occurred during a procedure to release so-called ‘‘Wigner’’ energy from the reactor core.

Table 1 Summary of the four nuclear accidents considered here.

Accident

Year

Sector

INES Category"

Windscale

1957

Military

5

Kyshtym

1957

Military

6

Three-Mile Island

1979

Civilian

5

Chernobyl

1986

Civilian

7

"International Nuclear Events Scale: Category 5 = accident with wider consequences; Category 6 = serious accident; Category 7 = major accident.

Table 2 Summary of previous major releases of radioactive material to the environment. Note that the summary is not comprehensive and only data for three radionuclides are presented. These release data should not be interpreted in terms of significance of the releases to envir­onmental or human health; the impact of radionuclide releases is not solely determined by the amount of radioactivity released. (Adapted from Smith & Beresford).48

Release of some key radionuclides to the environment (PBq)

Release event

Areab

137Cs

90Sr

131I

Chernobyl, 1986 (ref. 39)

Significant part of Europe

85

10

1760

Hiroshima atomic bomb, 1945"

(ref. 69)

Few km radius around epicentre

0.1

0.085

52

Atmospheric nuclear weapons testing, 1952-1981**

(ref. 70)

Global, primarily Northern Hemisphere

949

578

**

US atmospheric weapons tests, Nevada Test Site**’71

US states, particularly Nevada

**

**

5550 released to atmosphere, 1390 deposited to ground

Three Mile Island,

USA31’27

No significant environmental contamination

4.81 x 10-4

Mayak, discharges to the Techa River, 1949-56 (ref. 18)

Techa and Ob ivers

13

12

n. d.

Kyshtym accident, 1957 (ref. 18)

Approx.

30o km x 50 km area of Siberia

0.027

4

Waste discharges from Sellafield, 1964-92 (ref. 72)

Irish Sea

41

6

n. d.

Windscale accident, 1957 (ref. 1)

518 km2 area of Northern England

0.18

7.5 x 10-4

1.8

"Note that the radiation health effects of the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs resulted primarily from gamma and neutron radiation from the initial explosion. Radioactive fallout to the envir­onment (detailed here for Hiroshima) was minor in comparison.

b Indicative area only: the contaminated area depends on how you define ‘‘contaminated’’.

** 131I data is given for the US atmospheric weapons tests only: 137Cs and 90Sr data are global totals for the period 1952-1981.

Wigner energy is chemical potential energy stored in the lattice structure of the graphite moderator during operation of this type of nuclear reactor. The operators at Windscale routinely released this stored energy (to prevent an uncontrolled release) by an annealing process in which the core temperature was temporarily raised. This procedure normally released the Wigner energy in the graphite resulting in a temporary heating, then cooling of the core. On the day of the accident, however, the annealing process caused the temperature of some parts of the core to rise substantially. This, possibly coupled with rupture of a fuel element, caused the reactor to set on fire. After failed attempts to remove the overheated fuel elements and to put out the fire by carbon dioxide, the reactor was flooded with water on the following day (11th of October). The operators believed at the time that use of water carried the risk of a hydrogen explosion as it contacted red-hot metal, but it was felt that the risk of breach of containment by the burning reactor core was greater. By the evening of the 11th, the fire was fully extinguished.

The fire resulted in the release of ‘‘some of the fission products and activation products contained in a few percent of the core’’.1 The releases from the Windscale fire have recently been re-evaluated,1 giving estimates for a wide range of radionuclides including 1.8 PBq of 131I; 0.18 PBq of 137Cs and 0.042 PBq of 210Po. As with TMI and Chernobyl, large quantities of noble gases (including 26 PBq of 133Xe) were released, though these were less radiologically significant.