MSV Vs. Mean-Current CIC

Data taken on a commercial CIC were compared with commercial log-average-magnitude-squared (LAMS) units operating off fission counters in the EBR-2 shutdown gamma field of about 2 X 10s R/hr. The resulting curves, shown in Figs 5.26 and 5.27, are multivalued on the ordinate to emphasize the overlap As shown, the overlap for the CIC is only a factor of 2 compared to the overlap of

image199

image200

Fig 5.27—Comparison of CIC and LAMS units (Run 2)

 

the Gulf General Atomic counters of 100 If a true LRMS system had been used, the overlap would be the same or greater The improvement over a CIC is evident

Had the gamma field been more intense, the CIC overlap would be ml but the LAMS or log mean square voltage would still be 150. Table 5 2 shows comparative values of the discrimination ratio for the various systems

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Campbell, N R, The Study of Discontinuous Phenomena, Proc Cambridge Phil Soc, 15: 117, 310, 513 (1909-1910).

Chase, R L, Nuclear Pulse Spectrometry, McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., New York, 1961.

DuBndge, R A, J. P. Neissel, L. R. Boyd, W. K. Green, and H. W. Pielage, Reactor Control Systems Based on Counting and Campbelling Techniques, Final Progress Report, USAEC Report GEAP-4900, General Electric Company, July 1965.

Elmore, W C, and M. Sands, Electronics Experimental Techniques, McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc., New York, 1949

Fowler, E P, and R W. Levell, The Use of Current Fluctuations from a Neutron Detector with Logarithmic Amplifiers as a Measure of Neutron Flux Levels, British Report AEEW-R-375, June 1964.

Green, W К, Ten-Decade Wide Range Neutron Monitoring System, Final Test Report, USAEC Report GEAP-11094, General Electric Company, October 1970.

Gwinn, D A, andW. M. Trenholme, A Log-N and Period Amplifier Utilizing Statistical Fluctuation Signals from a Neutron Detec­tor, IEEE (Inst Elec Electron. Eng), Trans Nucl Set, NS-10(2) 1-9 (April 1963).

Harrer, J M, Nuclear Reactor Control Engineering, D Van Nostrand Company, Inc, Princeton, N J, 1963

Murphy, G, Elements of Nuclear Engineering, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York, 1961.

Popper, G F, Counting and Campbelling A New Approach to Neutron-Detection Systems, Reactor Fuel Process Technol, 10(3) 199 (Summer 1967).

___ , W C Lipinski, and J M Harrer, Ten Decades of Continuous

Neutron Flux Monitoring from a Single Fixed Position Detector, Trans Amer Nucl Soc, 9(1) 316-317 (June 1966)

Thomas, H A, and A C. McBride, Gamma Discriminations and Sensitivities of Averaging and RMS Type Detector Circuit for Campbelling Channels, Report GA-8035, Gulf General Atomic.

Trenholme, W M, and D J Keefe, A Neutron Flux Measuring Channel Covering Ten Decades of Reactor Power with a Single Fixed Position Detector, IEEE (Inst Elec Electron Eng), Trans Nucl Sci, NS-14(l) 253-260 (February 1967).