Safety analyses of Slovak steam generators and latest upgrades

The safe and reliable operation of steam generators is the essential pre-condition for the safe operation of the whole NPP, but also for all economical parameters at the unit. The steam generator has to be able to transfer the heat from the reactor in all operating or accidental regimes.

It is well-known that VVER-440 units have the horizontal steam generators with much higher capacity of cooling water in tank than in vertical steam generators, which are normally used in western NPPs. Undoubtedly; these horizontal steam generators are safer. On the other hand, due to horizontal design as well as in total 6 loops with additional welds and pumps cover a huge area, which is a limiting factor for containment construction of the unit. The exchange of steam generators is extremely difficult (in some reactor types almost impossible), therefore their optimal operation and clever maintenance (upgrades) is one of essential duty of NPP staff.

Based on operational experiences, the mitigation of damages and leak tightness defects in pipelines or collectors require much more time and money, than prevention measures. It is necessary to keep in mind the actual development in nuclear industry towards NPP lifetime prolongation and power increase (one of essential goals of European Commission 7FP — NULIFE). Fortunately, VVER-440 steam generators were designed with the huge power reserve (possible overloading of 20%). Beside several leakages in primary pipelines (0I6 mm), which can be in case of VVER-440 SGs relatively easy solved (blended), the corrosion deposits in feed water pipeline system occurred at many VVER-440 units [9]. The identified damages were caused mostly due to corrosion/ erosion processes attacking materials familiarly called "black steels" with insufficient resistance against corrosion.

Based on experience from Finland, also other countries including Slovakia changed the old feed water pipeline system. At this moment we would like to mention that the incident at the 2nd unit of NPP Paks (Hungary, 2003) connected to cleaning of fuel assemblies in special tank had the root causes in insufficient passivation of pipelines in SG after the steam water pipeline system exchange in 1997.

All steam generators at four VVER-440 units in Bohunice were gradually changed. At that time, there were two possibilities for the new feed water pipeline system. Out from two conceptions: Vitkovice a. s. design and OKB Gidropress design. The first solution was selected and lately improved to so called "Bohunice solution". Actually, experience from the last 10 years after upgrade was utilized.

A detailed description of VVER-440 steam generators delivered to NPP Bohunice is in [10­12]. The safety analyses were performed in 1977 by OKB Gidropress according to the Russian norms. The Russian designer and producer made the feed water pipelines (secondary side) from the carbon steel (GOST norm 20K and 22K). Water inlet pipeline was connected to the T-junction. From this point, 2 lines of the pipe with nozzles distributed the cooling secondary water in the space between primary pipes. Several problems having occurred in other NPPs were published in [13-16]. A disadvantage of such steam generators are difficult accessibility to the T-junction and next pipelines in the bundle.