Comparison between biomass power generation and the other

Biomass generation technology is compared with the other generation technology (coal fired, oil fired, LNG fired, hydropower, ocean thermal energy conversion, photovoltaic). The biomass power generation is defined as the scale that can manage as much as biomass grown by 30km2 afforestation in North America, Indonesia, and Brazil. Annual quantity of sending end generation and power station scale of each power station are shown in table 6.3.2.

The CO2 emission per 1kWh of each generation plant can be found dividing the sum of CO2 emission on power station construction and operation (fuel burning and maintenance repair) by the amount of total generated energy, assuming durability year of each generation plant. The durability of all power stations was defined as 30 years here.

Table 6.3.3 and Fig. 6.3.1 show each plant CO2 emission based on LCA. While facilities of biomass power generation have a similarity to thermal power generation by fossil fuel, CO2 emission per unit electricity of the biomass generation has a drastic reduction because CO2 emission on the biomass combustion is not counted. About CO2 emission, biomass power

generation is a highly competitive technology to the other renewable energy generation.

Table 6.3.2. Plant Scale of Various Power Generation Station.

Type of Generation

Annual Generation [kWh/y]

Plant Scale [MW]

References

Coal Fired

6.08 X109

1000

Uchiyama et al. , 1991

Oil Fired

6.17 X109

1000

Uchiyama et al. , 1991

LNG Fired

6.34 X109

1000

Uchiyama et al. , 1991

Hydropower

3.93 X107

10

Resources Council, 1983

OTEC (2.5MW)

8.76 X 106

2.5

Resources Council, 1983

OTEC (100MW)

5.70 X108

100

Tahara et al., 1993

Photovoltaic (Indonesia)

1.18 X107

10

Inaba et al., 1995

Photovoltaic (Japan)

8.64 X 106

10

Inaba et al., 1995

Biomass Fired ( North America )

1.04 X109

197

Tahara et al., 1998

Biomass Fired ( Indonesia )

1.65 X108

94

Tahara et al., 1998

Biomass Fired (Brazil)

5.98 X108

114

Tahara et al., 1998

Table 6.3.3. Unit CO2 Emission of Various Power Generation.

Type of Generation

Unit CO2 Emission [kg-CO2/kWh]

Coal Fired

0.916

Oil F ired

0.756

LNG Fired

0.563

Hydropower

0.017

OTEC (2.5MW)

0.119

OTEC (100MW)

0.014

Photovoltaic (Indonesia)

0.148

Photovoltaic (Japan)

0.187

Biomass Fired (North

America)

0.081

Biomass Fired (Indonesia)

0.119

Biomass Fired (Brazil)

0.024

image119

Fig. 6.3.1. Unit CO2 Emission of Various Power Generation.