Development of Sustainable Willow Short Rotation Forestry in Northern Europe

Theo Verwijst, Anneli Lundkvist, Stina Edelfeldt and Johannes Albertsson

Additional information is available at the end of the chapter http://dx. doi. org/10.5772/55072

1. Introduction

Modern willow short rotation forestry is based on traditional woodland management which uses the ability of certain tree species to grow new shoots from the stump after being cut down. Depending on site fertility, growing season length, initial planting density and species, willows may be coppiced from once a year to every fifth year, and the stands may remain productive over several decades. Traditionally, small-scale willow plantations have been used for fuel, fodder, convenience wood, basked making, bee keeping, and for horticultural purposes. Willows also may be used for erosion control, including wind and water erosion, and to avoid snow drift along roads. While the traditional use of willow is declining rapidly in Europe, the use of willow as an alternative crop for farmers has led to an increasing interest in willow breeding and cultivation [1]. A renewed research effort on short rotation willow coppice plantations in Sweden commenced in the late 1960’s due to a predicted shortage of raw materials for the pulp and paper industries, which turned out to be a false alarm. However, the 1970’s energy crisis constituted a new driver to continue research on willows as a source of biomass for energy purposes. Additional drivers, such as employment issues in the Swedish country side, and environmental concerns also influenced research funding rates and directions towards willow short rotation coppice. In the late 1980’s willow growing for energy was implemented at a larger scale and commercialized in Sweden. A tax on carbon dioxide emissions for the combustion of fossil fuel in heat production was introduced by the Swedish government during the 1990’s and created more favorable market conditions for investment in and implementation of biofuel systems [2]. In 1996, Sweden joined the European Union, which employed an agricultural policy in which subsidy levels to farmers constantly were altered and adapted to short term market situations. As willow growing is a long term commitment which requires longer term investments, this EU-policy promoted the use of annual crops, and the exponential increase of areas under willow cultivation leveled out after 1996 and even started to decline.

© 2013 Verwijst et al., licensee InTech. This is an open access chapter distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons. org/licenses/by/3.0), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.

In the meantime, the Swedish concept of large-scale willow cultivation for bioenergy purposes was exported to several EU-countries, notably to the UK and Poland, and a development of similar growing systems also was pursued overseas, in New Zealand and in the USA [3].

It was recognized early that willow growth concurs with potentially high evapotranspiration rates [4] and high nitrogen retention rates [5]. Willow species also may exhibit selective uptake of heavy metals [6], which underlies the potential to use willow as a phytoextractor for e. g. Cd from polluted soils [7]. These special traits of willow have allowed a further development of short-rotation willow coppice systems for environmental purposes [8]. Willow growing systems may be used as vegetation filters for purification of waste water [9], for cleaning of polluted drainage water from agricultural land [10] and as a recipient of nutrients from municipal sludge [11]. As willow stands are harvested at regular intervals, the pollutants are removed from the soil-plant system, while added nutrients and water enhance the systems’ biomass production. These systems then function as multi­purpose systems, simultaneously aiming at biomass production for energy purposes and provision of environmental services, while producing clean water and neutralizing potentially hazardous compounds. Several efforts have been made to assess the economic gains of such multi-purpose systems [e. g. 12, 13], and Volk et al. [3] concluded that the economic valuation of the environmental benefits is necessary for a further deployment of woody crops.

In the following sections, a brief overview will be given of the plant material and growing system used in willow short — rotation forestry (SRF) and of the history of willow research, with a focus on the developments in Sweden. We then continue with a description of the development and implementation of willow SRF in commercial practice, and with the current guidelines for commercial willow growing. We also present an update of recent research, performed to improve the productivity and sustainability of willow short rotation forestry as an agricultural crop for bioenergy purposes, and include some results of ongoing research projects.