The effect of waste concentration on hydrogen production

The effect of waste concentration was studied with inoculum concentration of 30% ( 0.36 dry wt/l) and light intensity of 9 klx. The following waste concentration were used: 5, 10, 20, 40, 60% v/v in case of dairy waste, 1, 3, 5, 10, 20% v/v in case of brewery waste I and 5, 10, 20, 40, 80% v/ v in case of brewery waste II. The results in Tabl.4 show the maximum hydrogen production of 3.2 l/l medium occurring when 40% of dairy waste was used. When brewery waste with high COD (220 g O2/l) was applied, 2.2 l of H2 per l medium was produced (waste concentration10% v/v). In case of brewery waste with low COD (27 g O2/l) only 0.67 l of H2 per l medium was produced (waste concentration 80 % v/ v). If higher concentrations of wastes were applied, the efficiency of hydrogen production was lower, which was caused by and inhibiting concentration of N-NHC (40 mg/l for dairy waste and 96 mg/l for brewery waste) (Waligorska, 2009, Melis, 2006). Such concentration of ammonium ions can diminish significantly the overall generation of hydrogen. The presence of ammonium ions as well as N2 causes reduction of nitrogen via nitrogenase into gaseous NH3 instead of required hydrogen. The amount of evolved CO2 never exceeded 10 vol. %. Additionally, higher concentrations of wastes caused acidification of medium during the process and darkens the medium, which makes the access of the light into the medium more difficult and negatively impact on hydrogen production. The final pH values presented on fig. 6 show the drop from 7.1 to 5.2 in case of brewery waste and 7.5 to 5.7 in case of dairy waste. This effect is caused mainly by formation of organic acids (lactic and acetic) (Koku, 2002). The higher was the concentration of the waste the higher was the amount of detected acids and lower value of pH. This can be explained by higher ability of transfer of undissociated form of acids towards the cell, followed by dissociation inside the cell, proton release and final inhibition of the process (Van Ginkel, 2005).

standard dairy brewery

Подпись: Fig. 5. The effect of inoculum concentration on hydrogen production

waste waste

Dairy waste (COD = 46 g O2/l)

Concentration of dairy waste

Hmax

COD loss

Ysub

Ysp

(% v/v)

(l/l medium)

(gO2/l medium) (l H2/l waste)

(l H2/ CODloss)

5

0.77

1.3

11.3

0.6

10

1.58

1.8

13.7

0.78

20

2.1

2.8

9.4

0.75

40

3.2

4.2

7.6

0.76

60

0

Brewery waste I (COD = 220 g O2/l)

1

0.86

1.9

56

0.45

3

1.17

2.4

29

0.49

5

1.4

2.8

22

0.51

10

2.24

3.8

19

0.59

20

0.52

2.3

1.1

0.23

Brewery waste II (COD = 27 g O2/l)

5

0.38

1.3

3.6

0.29

10

0.4

1.5

2.0

0.27

20

0.4

1.6

1.0

0.25

40

0.56

2.4

0.9

0.23

80 (concentrated)

0.67

2.8

0.59

0.24

Standard (L-malic acid)

0.2

2.3

1.9

1.2

Table 4. The correlation between waste concentration, amount of hydrogen produced, COD loss and efficiencies.

image118

pH biomass COD

increase loss

a) brewery waste (Seifert, 2010)

image119

pH biomass COD

increase loss

b) dairy waste

Fig. 6. Influence of food wastewater concentration on pH, biomass increase and COD loss.

With the rising concentration of wastes we observed higher COD loss, biomass increase and increase of specific efficiency (Table 4, fig.6). With further increase of waste concentration COD loss and specific efficiency were lower. However substrate efficiency decreases with higher waste concentration. Similar results showed Eroglu et al. obtaining the best substrate efficiency of hydrogen generation (0.1g/l waste) for low waste concentration (olive mill wastewater 2%) however maximum volume of hydrogen production (0.45 l/l) and highest COD loss (40%) were observed when higher waste concentrations were used (Eroglu, 2004). Also Mohan et al. studding hydrogen production from vegetable based market waste, obtained good specific efficiency when low waste concentrations were used, however highest COD loss (almost 60%) occurred when higher waste concentrations were introduced to the media (Mohan, 2009). Comparing the above results with the ones obtained for hydrogen generation on standard medium with L-malic acid, it can be seen that total amount of produced hydrogen is by 30% higher when dairy waste in concentration of 40%v/ v was used and comparable when brewery waste with high COD was used (Table 4, Fig 7). Different papers published so far have proved that organic substrates such as glucose, sucrose, malic acid have been more effective than the waste containing media (Yetis2000, Zhu, 1999, Basak, 2009). However based on our results we can state that wastes studied in this paper represent an effective nutrient for photobiological hydrogen production.

image120

Fig. 7. The effect of optimum waste concentration on hydrogen production (30% v/ v inoculum, 9 klx)