MSR fuel cycles and fuel

The design of molten salt reactors is similar to those for other thermal reactors, including similar neutron fluxes and reactivity temperature coefficients (Rosenthal et al., 1972). In particular, the graphite-moderated MSR has much in common with the HTR: a graphite moderator at an average temperature of 600-700 °C, Th-233U fuel cycle, and similar fuel-moderator ratios. However, there are some important differences. Table 13.9 shows some relevant parameters for MSR, using 233U or 235U as the fissile material. The main parameter shown in this table is the critical fuel concentration; to obtain the same reactivity only half as much 233U is needed as 235U, because of the superior neutronic characteristics of 233 U (Rosenthal et al., 1972). That is an important feature to take into account for the design of reactors that use Th as fertile material.

7LiF-BeF2 (66/34 in mol%) salt is used as the fuel carrier for the moderated (thermal) molten salt thorium breeder, producing 7LiF-BeF2-ThF4-UF4 as fuel salt. All of the alternatives to this salt reduce the breeding capacity of the reactor

Table 13.9 Predicted and observed critical fuel concentration in an MSR (Rosenthal et al., 1972)

Concentration (g/litre)1

235U loading2

233U loading3

Predicted concentration

32.8

15.1 ± 0.14

Observed concentration5

32.8 ± 0.3

15.4 ± 0.1

Observed/predicted6

1.00 ± 0.01

1.02 ± 0.01

Notes:

1 Fissile uranium, grams per litre of salt.

2 See Ref. 9.

3 See Ref. 10.

4 Uncertainties in adjustments for residual plutonium and fission products from 235U run and for dimensional changes in graphite core structure due to fast-neutron irradiation.

Uncertainty due mainly to uncertainties in salt density and salt volume.

6 (M/k) (dk/dM) = 0.36; 1% 6M ~ 0.4% 6k.

(Renault et al., 2009). SFR systems use a molten salt actinide burner. A carrier salt with good solubility for actinide trifluorides is needed; something which can be achieved using 7LiF-NaF-(KF) as the solvent or 7LiF-(NaF)-BeF2 melt. An interesting alternative is the use of Pu and MAs as start-up fuel for the Th cycle in the MSR, leading to 7LiF-NaF-ThF4 carrier salt (Renault et al., 2009). A single stream Li, Na, Be/F molten salt actinide recycler and transmuter (MOSART) fast spectrum system fuelled by combinations of Pu with MA trifluorides (AnF3) from UOX and MOX has been developed in Russia (Ignatiev et al., 2005). A modified two-fluid Th-U molten salt system (based on MOSART) has also been developed more recently (Feynberg and Ignatiev, 2010). A comparison between MOSART, MSBR and MSFR is provided in Table 13.10 . In order to summarize different potential combinations, some reference salts and fuel compositions are reported in Table 13.11.

Salt processing relies on both on-line and batch processes to maintain smooth reactor operation while minimizing losses to waste streams. The removal of lanthanides is necessary because of their low solubility in the molten salt and their adverse effect on reactivity through neutron capture (Renault et al., 2009). A potential processing scheme is shown in Fig. 13.14 . The main innovation is stages 2 and 3, which combine chemical and electrochemical extraction methods with the back extraction of actinides and lanthanides. This allows fuel processing to occur with no variation in effluent volume, while reducing the fuel processing balance to just one reaction: 2LnF. + 3H. O(g) = Ln. O3 + 6HFfe). An effective method for actinide/lanthanide separation is still needed (Delpech et al., 2008). A practicable fuel clean-up rate is 40 l per day, corresponding to the

Table 13.10 The basic characteristics of MSBR, MSFR and MOSART (Feynberg and Ignatiev, 2010)

MSBR [3,4] MSFR [10] MOSART [6,13]

Type

breeder

breeder

burner/converter

Neutron

spectrum

thermal

fast

fast

Number of fluid

2

1

2

2

1

2

streams

Thermal capacity (MW)

2250

2250

3000

3000

2400

2400

Fuel salt

temperature (°C)

566/704

566/704

600/750

700/850

600/720

600/720

Fuel salt

68LiF

72LiF

77.5LiF

78LiF

72LiF

72LiF

composition

31 BeF2

16BeF2

20ThF4

16ThF4

27BeF2

27BeF2

(mol%)

0.2UF4

12ThF4

2.5UF4

6.5TRUF3

1TRUF3

1TRUF3

0.2UF4

Blanket salt

71 LiF

none

78LiF

78LiF

none

75LiF

composition

2BeF2

22ThF4

22ThF4

5BeF2

(mol%)

27ThF4

2 0ThF4

Fuel cycle

U-Th

U-Th

U-Th

TRU-Th-U

without U, Th

TRU-Th-

Fission product

30-50

10-30

418

418

300

300

removal time (epdf)

Table 13.11 Fuels and coolant salts for different applications (Renault et al., 2009)

Reactor

type

Neutron

spectrum

Application

Carrier salt

Fuel system

MSR-

breeder

Thermal

Non­

moderated

Fuel

Fuel

7LiF-BeF2 7Li F-Th F4

7LiF-BeF2-ThF4-UF4

7LiF-ThF4-UF4

7LiF-ThF4-PuF3

MSR-

breeder

T/NM

Secondary

coolant

NaF-NaBF4

MSR-

burner

Fast

Fuel

LiF-NaF LiF-(NaF)-BeF2 LiF-NaF-ThF4 2

LiF-(NaF)-AnF4-AnF3

LiF-(NaF)-BeF2-AnF4-AnF3

AHTR

Thermal

Primary

coolant

7LiF-BeF2

SFR

Intermediate

coolant

NaNO3-KNO3

-(NaNO2)

image134

13.14 Thorium molten salt reactor (TMSR) (MSFR) reference fuel salt processing (Renault et al., 2009).

processing of 100 kg heavy nuclei per day. This value is almost two orders of magnitude lower than that needed by the reference MSBR scheme (Renault et al., 2009).