Soil Conservation and Protection

The major threats to the ability of soils to sustain highly productive forest, other than nutrition-related issues discussed in Sect. 10.3.1, is soil displacement, soil erosion and soil compaction.

When viewed simplistically, soil compaction sensitivity by mechanical equip­ment is strongly related to machine mass, soil texture and soil water content at the time of impact. Coarse textured soils such as sands can be trafflced by fairly heavy loads with low risk of compaction in both wet and dry conditions (Smith et al. 1997a, b; du Toit et al. 2010; Ponder et al. 2012). Soils with very sandy textures seldom suffer from compaction problems and may even experience improved water holding capacity and sometimes improved growth following moderate compaction (Smith et al. 1997b; du Toit et al. 2010; Ponder et al. 2012). Conversely, soils with a fairly even mixture of particle size classes such as sandy loams, loams and sandy clay loams are moderately compactable when dry but strongly compactable when moist (Smith et al. 1997a, b; du Toit et al. 2010). Harvesting operations should where possible be scheduled to avoid soils with an even particle size distributions during wet conditions. Furthermore, machines travelling on plantation soils could be matched with the soils load bearing capacity, which is strongly related to texture, organic matter and initial bulk density (Ampoorter et al. 2012). Most compacting occurs in soils with the first few passes of machines over a specific area. This fact, combined with efforts to limit the spatial extent of compaction, calls for controlled vehicular movement on designated skid trails (Ampoorter et al. 2010). The effects of compaction in short-rotation bio-energy plantations can be thus minimised (a) by using designated skid trials, (b) by matching machine mass with soil texture and thus with load bearing ability, (c) by limiting harvesting operations on fine textured soils during wet conditions and (d) by retaining as much of the harvesting residue as is possible, given the harvesting system chosen.

The sustainability of bio-energy plantations will be severely compromised if erosion rates significantly exceed soil formation rates. Soil erosion is generally affected by rainfall & runoff, slope gradient and length, soil erodibility, vegetation cover and soil surface cover, soil tillage, and any other man-made support practices to limit erosion, e. g. contour banks or windbreaks.

On a site with a give soil, slope and climate, forest management practices can play a major role in limiting erosion. The single factor giving the most effective protection against wind, rain-splash and water erosion is the presence of absence of a soil cover layer, e. g. a mulch layer in agricultural fields or, the forest floor/slash layer in plantations and forests (Morgan 1995). This is echoed by several case studies where forest floor layers have been removed or destroyed by intensive fires (du Toit 2002; Miura et al. 2003; Fernandez et al. 2004). Soil loss through erosion in plantation-based systems therefore depends very strongly on management of the slash and the forest floor. If destruction of the slash/forest floor is combined with other factors that favour soil erosion, it often results in an increase in erosion by orders of magnitude. Sherry (1953,1954,1961,1964,1971) documented the effects

Table 10.3 Average soil loss over two crop cycles of short-rotation Acacia mearnsii plantations under varying management regimes

Number of erosion enhancing factors present

Description

Soil loss (tons ha-1)

One

Steep slopes

Nil

Slash burning

0-0.8

Hoeing to control weeds

0-0.4

Two

Burning on slopes

11.4

Burning and hoeing

10.1-17.6

Hoeing on slopes

4.6

Three

Burn C Hoe on slopes

113.7

From du Toit (2002); after the work of Sherry (1953, 1954, 1961,

1964, 1971)

of three factors: slash burning, slope steepness and soil tillage (and combinations thereof) on soil erosion. The results have been re-analysed by du Toit (2002) and show an order of magnitude increase in soil erosion with the number of factors present (Table 10.3).

In non-planted areas, road design, construction and maintenance is critically important to minimize erosion because cuttings and road construction will lay the soil bare and poor road drain maintenance may cause the water flow to be concentrated in certain areas.